Bové’s pipe in pieces

José Bové, the charismatic, moustachioed, pipe-smoking sheep farmer, French to his finger-tips and educated in the United States, is due to tell us on Thursday whether or not he is running for president. The press and M. Bové assume he will. I can understand why he thinks he should: neither the extreme left nor the Greens are yet making any kind of mark in the polls (they each poll around 4%). He on the other hand is hugely popular: he has great charisma, he is French to his finger tips and he farms sheep. He goes to prison regularly for destroying GM crops and he smokes a pipe. What other qualifications do you need to be the most powerful president in the world?

Well, until about 10 days ago, one would have said “Not much”. But if Ségolène Royal’s gaffs and consequent drop in the polls have done nothing else, they have shown us that actually the French do want something else. They want someone who knows what they’re talking about and who carries within them a total awareness of what responsability means. And I think even M. Bové would agree that he has not got much of that. He is the champion of the anti-globalisation left, the left which believes that big gestures (destroying fields of GM crops, brandishing your hand-cuffed wrists to the TV cameras) replace big ideas. A CSA poll released yesterday shows that 71% of French people do not want him to stand: more importantly, 68% of those on the left said they do not want him to stand. His time has past. He was at the height of his popularity in the summer of 2003, and it was precisely then, at the fête de l’Humanité, the Communist Party newspaper, that he told the press he was not interested in politics. I can only hope he remembers that wise decision, for while it is true that the extreme left, and the Greens now that M. Hulot has taken his holiday, lack a credible voice, his husky, tobacco-stained tones are not what they need.

But it is equally true that if he does not stand, the extreme left will wither. Knowing that, there is considerable pressure on him from the internet begging him to run: in very few days 15,000 signed a petition. That has now been doubled. Bové says that touches him deeply, but as Ségolène Royal has found out, there is a world of difference between having the support of even a couple of hundred thousand well-meaning internet well-wishers, and facing the implacable efficiency of the Sarkozy machine. If the French information-gathering police, the Renseignements Généraux, had fun digging around the Socialist Party’s environment spokesman for his past with Greenpeace, just imagine what a field-day they will have with Bové! And as of today they’ll be watching his iconic pipe with an eagle eye: how can he give a press conference on Thursday without it? Yet if he has it, it will have to be unlit - and that would show how much he relies on sham stage effects. Will he smoke it to provoke? That’s probably the question which will grip France on Thursday morning. Which shows to what depths it has all sunk.

3 Responses to “Bové’s pipe in pieces”

  1. Wint Discontent Says:

    José Bové is also well known for having, with a group of angry supporters, destroyed the Mc Donald restaurant in Millau in 1999, for which he was condemned and jailed. It’s not exactly like US citizens pouring out French wine ( Burgundy, but not Bordeaux if I remember) in the streets or boycotting Roquefort and foie gras. If he is canddidate and uses the same methods of self promotion, we shall have a good time.
    You should note also that just as Bové is a perfect replica of Asterix, Mr Nicolas Hulot is a pale replica of Mr Hulot, Jacques Tati’s character in Les vacances de M. Hulot (1957).

  2. Tim Says:

    Certainly one should not allow a confusion of pipes - or let their smoke cloud the issue. In my memory, M. Hulot (the real one - created by Jacques Tati) kept his pipe upside-down (and empty?) at all times, whereas M. Bové’s is used to show gritted teeth below the bristling moustache. Harold Wilson, the former British prime minister, never lit his pipe either - it was used as a symbol of deep wisdom, much as Bové’s.

  3. Wint Discontent Says:

    To be precise, and in these matters one should, Mr Hulot’s pipe is *full* of tobacco, but not lit.
    This is very interesting within the context of no smoking regulations to be implemented soon in French public places.
    Nobody has thought of letting people buy as many cigarettes and cigars as they wish, but of forbidding then to light them.
    Both commerce and the health system would benefit from it. In the same spirit I suggest *simulating* a presidential election.
    Everyone would go to vote, but no one would be elected.

Leave a Reply